Sunday, October 15, 2023

Defining Barbarity: A Prerequisite for Dialogue Among Civilizations

The dialogue of civilizations is a noble pursuit that seeks to foster understanding, cooperation, and mutual respect among diverse cultures and traditions. Before embarking on this journey of discourse, learning, and negotiation, it is essential to delineate what is considered barbarity in our contemporary global society. While cultures and faith systems have diverse practices that are deeply rooted in history, there are certain elements that must be unequivocally closed off and rejected in the quest for a common understanding of acceptable civilizations and practices during both times of peace and war. This essay explores the importance of recognizing and defining barbarity in the context of a changing world, where our understanding of acceptable practices has evolved significantly.

Barbarity and the Recognition of Unacceptable Practices

In the pursuit of a meaningful dialogue among civilizations, it is imperative to acknowledge that not all cultural or historical practices are deserving of recognition or respect. Certain practices, irrespective of their historical or cultural roots, fall unequivocally under the banner of barbarity. The recognition and rejection of these practices are vital to distinguish between civilization and barbarity. Here are a few such examples:

Honor Killing: Honor killings, which involve the murder of individuals, typically women, who are perceived to have brought shame to their families, must be unequivocally condemned. These acts have no place in any civilized society and represent a blatant violation of human rights.

Female genital mutilation: The partial or total removal of a girl's external genitalia for non-medical reasons, often causing severe physical and psychological harm. This harmful practice is rooted in cultural and traditional beliefs, but it violates human rights, poses serious health risks, and perpetuates gender inequality.

(Modern) Slavery: Slavery in any form is a deplorable practice that goes against the principles of human dignity, equality, and freedom. The existence of modern slavery is a grave injustice that demands a unified global response.

Sati: Sati, the historical practice of self-immolation by widows on their husband's funeral pyres, is a deeply troubling tradition that has rightly been condemned and prohibited.

Human Sacrifice: Human sacrifice, in any form or context, is an inhumane act that can never be justified. Such acts have been widely rejected and considered barbaric across civilizations.

Defining Barbarity in a Changing World

The concept of barbarity is not static; it evolves with time and our collective moral progress. What was once accepted may now be considered barbaric, and what is considered not barbaric today may be viewed differently in the future. The changing understanding of barbarity reflects our ongoing commitment to higher ethical standards and human rights.

In recent years, the term "barbarity" has gained prominence in discussions of terrorist organizations and state sponsors of terrorism. While some may argue that labeling certain groups as barbaric is politically incorrect, it is a reflection of the growing recognition that there are practices and actions that transcend cultural relativism and must be condemned universally.


The Path Forward: Building a Common Understanding

To improve the dialogue among diverse civilizations, traditions, and cultures, the precondition is to have a common shared recognition of what constitutes barbarity in our contemporary global society. This recognition serves as a foundation for mutual respect and understanding, allowing us to distinguish between acceptable and unacceptable practices. The process of defining barbarity is not an arbitrary exercise but a dynamic one that reflects the evolving ethical standards of humanity.

Conclusion

In the pursuit of dialogue among civilizations, it is crucial to acknowledge that not all practices deserve respect or recognition. Defining barbarity in our contemporary global society is an essential step in building bridges and fostering understanding among diverse cultures and traditions. The evolution of humanity's conception of barbarity reflects our commitment to higher ethical standards and human rights. While recognizing the changing nature of this concept, we can collectively work toward a more just and compassionate world where barbarity has no place, and universal values of human dignity, equality, and freedom are upheld.

Narratives of the Future: China, Rockefeller, and the Battle for Global Cooperation

By Victor V. Motti* In an era of fragmented trust, outdated institutions, and looming existential risks, everyone seems to be asking the sam...